The Cat Bible Q&A
Tracie welcomes any and all questions about cats AND dogs on both her live radio shows. Call in to DOG TALK on Saturdays from 11-Noon (EST) to 800-394-8830 or Wednesdays 8-9 PM (EST) to CAT CHAT 866-675-6675. (You don't need to have Sirius to call in!)
Cat With Numerous Feeding Issues
I need some help . I really want to find a better diet for my cat Smokey who is about 11 years old. He is neutered and all of his vaccinations are current.
About 4 years ago he was diagnosed with oxalate crystals. Our vet at the time prescribed Science Diet X/D. (A side note we were also moving at the time, which we do quite often being a military family. I'm sure he was pretty stressed out.)
Smokey is obese. He is currently 15 pounds (down from 17.5) which my current vet is telling me is about 5 pounds more than his ideal weight.
Here are the things that I have learned that I have been doing wrong (thanks to your show) and have contributed negatively to his health.
1. Smokey is on feline x/d, but it is dry. I now know dry food is a major no no. But when I try to give him wet, even when mixed with dry food, he vomits.
2. I was allowing him to free feed. My vet told me that this goes against how cats eat in nature and has turned him into a fat, lazy, couch potato. At his recommendation, I now feed him once a day and only leave the food down for 1 hour. Using this technique he has lost 2.5 pounds.
Here are my questions:
1. I know that I am feeding Smokey "kitty crack". How do I get him off the junk when he vomits every time I feed him wet food?
2. Do I need to feed him the x/d??? My vet doesn't offer any alternatives. Can you recommend an alternative diet?
3. How do I help Smokey continue to lose and get down to a healthy weight?
Smokey is an important part of our family. We want him to have a long healthy life. Please help me start doing the right things.
Thank you
Heather
New Bern, NC
The first thing you need to do is read the Q&A's on www.CatChatRadio.com to learn more about good nutrition for your Smokey and answers for many of your concerns. I spend a great deal of time answering and posting Q&A's and I wish more people would take advantage of them, since they have the answers to questions like yours.You would know that the dry prescription foods sold by vets both create and maintain life-threatening medical conditions in cats.
Dr Elizabeth Hodgkins, the official vet of Cat Chat, also suggested that you go to www.catnutrition.org to educate yourself.
We also want to assure you that your cat won't vomit all wet foods. You need to keep looking for a good canned (she should try Fancy Feast among others that are on the approved list (PDF File) at CatChatRadio.com) and or try raw (including Feline's Pride).
You definitely do need to switch foods because the dose of food you are getting now is not supplying his nutrient needs and he is likely to become diabetic soon if you don't get the carbs out of his diet.
By the way, you are not the cause of your cat's obesity - the recommendations from your vet are at the heart of the problem.
Tracie Hotchner
The information contained in the answers posted on this board comes from THE CAT BIBLE: Everything Your Cat Expects You To Know, and from CAT CHAT™ The Radio Show, broadcasting live on Martha Stewart Living Radio, Channel 112 on Sirius Satellite Radio, every Wednesday from 8-9 p.m. EST.
Note: Some of the answers to the questions below are explained in greater detail in PDF files. Go here to get the free Adobe Acrobat reader.
Click on the button above to download Adobe's FREE Acrobat Reader.
DISCLAIMER: Please be aware that the advice I give on the air or in emails – or those you see posted here – are not intended to take the place of a veterinarian's advice or expertise. I say this to protect myself from being misunderstood or from your over-reliance on my advice in situations where your pet may be seriously ill and you would mistakenly delay seeking medical intervention. While I am confident in the research-based facts and common-sense advice I can offer, it is never meant to be used at the exclusion of trained, accredited and board certified professionals. But I also have this disclaimer to protect your dog – because what you learn from me is not intended to take the place of medical care or professional evaluation – on the contrary, my desire is to equip you with information that will allow you to enjoy your pets to the fullest, and also to encourage you to seek professional medical attention whenever there are physical symptoms or an overall change in your pet's attitude.
Tracie welcomes any and all questions about cats AND dogs on both her live radio shows. Call in to DOG TALK on Saturdays from 11-Noon (EST) to 800-394-8830 or Wednesdays 8-9 PM (EST) to CAT CHAT 866-675-6675. (You don't need to have Sirius to call in!)

![]()





